Example 1 — Credit cards to personal loan. Total debt: $14,000, current weighted APR: 22%, consolidation APR: 10%, payment: $400/month. Current path: 49 months, $5,500 interest. Consolidated path: 41 months, $2,300 interest. Net savings: roughly $3,200 before fees. With a 3% origination fee ($420), net savings are about $2,780.
Example 2 — Small rate reduction. Total debt: $8,000, current APR: 16%, consolidation APR: 12%, payment: $250/month. Current path: 39 months, $1,700 interest. Consolidated: 36 months, $1,200 interest. Savings: roughly $500. After a 2% fee ($160), net savings drop to $340. Consolidation helps here but the benefit is modest—DIY payoff may be simpler.
Example 3 — Large debt, significant rate drop. Total debt: $35,000, current APR: 21%, consolidation APR: 8%, payment: $800/month. Current: 67 months, $18,600 interest. Consolidated: 51 months, $5,800 interest. Savings: approximately $12,800—substantial enough to clearly justify consolidation even with a 5% origination fee ($1,750).